Florida couple left homeless after house they leased wasn't allowed to be rented out

Posted at 5:03 PM, Jan 10, 2022

NORTH FORT MYERS, Fla. — A Florida couple was renting what they thought was the perfect home, and as they moved in, they learned a rule didn't allow them to stay. Now, they are left homeless.

“It was the perfect house for us. So we like the house, the neighborhood in the location in the price range. The price was perfect too," Annette Kriete said.

A perfect home, she said. That is an ideal distance from their family. The five-month search for a home for herself and her partner, Michael Simon, was over. The couple was relieved.

“It was a lot of stressful months trying to find the house that market is up right now," Kriete said.

The couple moved into the home in North Fort Myers on New Year's Eve.

“Everything was going to be really nice. I thought, and then we got the bad news," Simon said.

That same day the couple was told they couldn't stay because of a Property Owners Association rule. The president of the POA told them there was a rule that doesn't allow homeowners to rent their property.

“He said, well, that's not allowed. That's going to be a problem," Kriete said.

The couple was in-shock after forking out thousands of dollars for their rental.

“From what they're saying is they don't want to have to pressure us into leaving, but we have to just because of the rules," Simon said.

Finding another place to rent in a short time frame, they said, is nearly impossible.

“I've been in tears. I've had migraine headaches, which I don't usually get unless I'm under stress, and I'm getting them every day right now," Kriete said.

She now spends hours outside of work and frantically searching for another home on her weekends, but she said time is ticking.

“They have offered our money back, but they're asking us to hurry and leave," she said.

For now, they live with only the essentials. They live out of boxes and bags.

Kriete said they had explored other options, but most were too costly.

“You know, find Airbnb, which is going to cost us out of our pocket. We came up with a lot of money to move into this house," she said.

The pair wants time to find another place and load up their things again and move to another home.

Fox 4 spoke with the president of the Terrapin Woods POA. He said, "the rules are the rules." He said the rules state that renting in the neighborhood isn't allowed.

Lauryn Moss at WFTX first reported this story.